Silent Light (2007): Movie Review

The Nature of Love

Movie: Silent Light

Dir: Carlos Reygadas

On the surface, Silent Light tells the story of the dilemma and pain involved when Johann seriously falls in love with Marrianne while he is still married to Esther. Theirs is a very Christian family in which a day begins with a silent prayer before having their food (be it cornflakes in the dining table or tacos on the back of a pickup) and Johann is this family man who can't afford to be one with Marrianne for the sake of maintaining the peace of his own household.

The Mexican countryside is peaceful and the only turbulence that seems to be disturbing this state of calm is the turbulence of love. “Peace is stronger than love” says Marrianne when she opines that they should call it quits after a brief episode of making love, maybe for the first and the last time. The sensual and caring nature of touch gains it’s own significance, be it while Johann shampoos his kids, massages their feet or while tenderly caressing Marianne. I couldn’t resist myself from getting reminded of the beautiful landscapes and sensual tangibles of a Terrence Malick movie (it might also be because I am more acquainted with his films as this is my first Carlos Reygadas film as a viewer). But unlike a Malick film which is profuse with voiceovers and Lubeski's running camera, Silent Light makes us to observe the nature and its landscapes before asking us to root for characters and the ensuing action. It’s a kind of detached filmmaking that doesn’t want to disrupt the calm that is on display. My favourite bit of the film was the driving scene where the husband and wife has a conversation about how things have turned bad in their relationship, while the car is driving on amidst the cornfields, with a sky full of dark clouds ready to pour down. And it does eventually crash down mercilessly, in an attempt to be one with the emotional turmoil of the people involved, in a rather unpretentious manner, rather than being overtly dramatic.

In the end, Silent Light is a pleasant film about the agony of love and how no one can foretell or change what fate or the Grace of God( as Johann’s father states that everything works according to His plans) has in store. Barry Jenkins’s once went to the extent of praising it without any bounds and calling it the best film of 21st century. I watched it while it was raining outside (not that it should be watched in the rainy season alone 🤤) and the state of calm the movie induces drove me into a pleasant mood of gleeful brooding. It's a fine film.👍

Comments

Movie Review: Thudarum (2025)

A searing drama against the corrupt system. Movie: Thudarum Dir: Tharun Moorthy Tharun Moorthy knows how to work with emotions which is a rarity in today's movies that tend to be always on the other side. It feels refreshing to see the tension that something bad is going to happen which the film carries all through its narrative. This makes it a very engaging watch, but this never feels forced at any point which is the quality of a well cooked drama. The story,which has been in K.R. Sunil's mind for years seems to have aged well, with Tharun Moorthy chipping in to complete the screenplay. Tharun's previous movie showed us how well he could bring the mental state of the characters on screen. The characterization of Sattar and his Umma made 'Saudi Vellaka' unforgettable. While he fought the issue of pendency of cases in it, here, he made use of Mohanlal's stardom to bring a poignant drama against the ...

Movie Review: The Olmo and the Seagull (2014)

Is Motherhood Sacred? Movie: The Olmo and the Seagull Dir: Petra Costa, Lea Glob “I feel like there’s an alien in my belly” says Olivia, a pregnant stage artist who is straddled between choosing a life of following her passion and her untimely pregnancy which alienates the woman from her own choices. The Olmo and the Seagull discusses the false imposition of undue importance to motherhood, which in fact takes its toll only on the women involved. The film meanders on a thin line between non-fiction and fiction and is played by real characters (Olivia Corsini and Serge Nikolai), with intermittent additions from the director’s angle to manipulate the setting of the cinema. What distinguishes cinema from a documentary is it’s power to manipulate the performers in action. The Olmo and the Seagull doesn’t intend to hide the timely interventions from the creator's side on the drama happening between the husband and the wife, it in fact showcases the directors' promts...

Anthology Overview: Small Axe (2020)

Uprising There's An Uprising Small Axe (Film Anthology) Dir: Steve McQueen So if you are the big tree We are the small axe Ready to cut you down To cut you down - Bob Marley Small axe is a masterpiece from Steve McQueen as all of the five films in the BBC original anthology tries (and wins almost perfectly) not only in expounding the issues faced by the Blacks but acts as a celebration of their eventual triumph over what was and is trying to pull them down. It tells five important stories drawn from the real life experiences of the West Indian community, who lived in Britain between the 1960s and 80s. The first film, Mangrove , tells the story of the Mangrove restaurant and the case of the nine people who initiated a protest against the police, who unlawfully seized and created fearful ruckus inside the place, which otherwise served as a cheerful place of community gathering for the Blacks. The co...

CINEMATHEQUE

Search This Blog